All states should be donor states as it makes no sense to collect money from a state and then send it all back to the same state. If it did there would be no reason to collect it from the states in the first place. As all Federal programs have a cost to them the only way to send more back to the states is to spend more than is brought in and run a deficit. The problem is not that some states are donor states, the problem is that some states are welfare states. The irony is that the representatives from these high cost states typically support more federal spending.
I agree that high cost of living states tend to pay more federal income taxes as the higher cost of living requires higher wages and we have a progressive tax structure that taxes higher wagers at a higher percentage. If they were arguing that each state should contribute the same dollar amount per person, I could partly agree with the logic. But even that logic is slightly flawed as the Federal employees in the high cost states also get paid more and the buildings cost more etc. In addition, California may be a donor state this year but if a major disaster strikes they will quickly get back more than they have been donating.
The easy way to be fair to all states is to have simple tax system that favors no states and then limit the Federal spending in each state to 20% less than what they pay into the federal government. The 20% is just an estimate, the actual amount needs to account for what we spend outside the USA in wars, military bases, foreign aid, the UN, interest on the debt etc.. Some would still complain as a large Naval base such as San Diego would consume a large portion of California's share. What this means is that other Federal spending on research, district courts etc.. would have to be in other states. This may even help to lower the high cost of living in California as there would be less demand for buildings, land and employees. States may start to argue in favor of closing an unneeded military base in their state to free up federal money for a research center or VA hospital instead of always fighting to keep every base open no matter what. This would also help reduce wasteful pork barrel spending as each wasteful project in their state would take away money from better projects in that state at not take from a endless money supply.
Libertarian Party of Catawba County
Have Us E-mail You The Latest News
LincolnHerald.net OR LincolnHerald.com
Your #1 Local Source for News, Sports, Opinion, Obituaries, Religion, Classifieds, Events, Photos, Community, Coupons, and more!
Serving Lincoln, Catawba, Gaston and Cleveland counties including the areas of Lincolnton, Denver, Maiden, Stanley, Alexis, Vale, Crouse, Iron Station, High Shoals and Cherryville.
Not a newspaper, not a magazine, we’re online – on your computer at home or work, on your smartphone… with news and more 24 hours a day, seven days a week, every day of the year including holidays.
Visit Our Facebook Page
DISCLAIMER: Opinions and letters published in the Lincoln Herald are not necessarily the views of the Editor, or Publisher. The Lincoln Herald reserves the right to edit or omit copy. Letters to the Editor must be attributed with a name, address and contact phone number – names and town of origin will be printed (not the phone number).