Community Living | Coupon | Police Scanner | E-News Signup | Archives | Merchant Directory | Dining Guide
Have a HOT TIP? Call 704-276-6587 Or E-mail us At
Lincoln Herald | Lincolnton, NC

GastonCollege729x90 Sept-Oct

home : state news : e-state news September 17, 2019

9/4/2019 5:41:00 AM
Court Tosses Gerrymandered Districts
Gaston County NC House districts among those to be redrawn

Wayne Howard
Staff Writer

On Tuesday (Sep. 3rd) a panel of three judges in Raleigh threw out North Carolina’s state legislative maps as an unconstitutional partisan gerrymander and ordered lawmakers to draw up new ones in two weeks.

The Republican leader of the State Senate, Phil Berger, said the Legislature would not appeal the ruling. The North Carolina Supreme Court, which would hear any appeal, is made up of six Democrats and one Republican.

The United States Supreme Court ruled in June, by a 5-to-4 margin, that federal courts could not remedy gerrymandering based on politics. In an earlier decision, the Court had ruled that it would hear cases based on racial gerrymandering. An earlier version of North Carolina's redistricting had been ruled to violate the
ban on racially gerrymandered districts.

In response to that decision, the GOP-dominated North Carolina legislature redrew the maps, but made it clear that it was doing so for partisan advantage, not racial advantage.

The effects of Tuesday's ruling, which requires new maps to be drawn and approved by September 18th, could go beyond state legislative maps which is what this lawsuit addressed. It appears likely that the ruling could be applicable to the Congressional district map, but a new lawsuit will likely be required to overturn those.

Tuesday’s decision appears to end one legal battle over the legislative maps that had already forced the redrawing of 28 districts found to be racial gerrymanders. Since Republicans drew the legislative boundaries eight years ago, the party has maintained healthy majorities — and often supermajorities — in the State House and the State Senate, even when Democrats won a majority of the vote statewide.

The 357-page decision Tuesday said the Republican-drawn maps violated the State Constitution’s clauses guaranteeing free elections, equal protection under the law and freedom of speech and assembly.

While the debate over gerrymandering has taken on a bitter partisan cast in recent years, the North Carolina judges went out of their way to make clear that their ruling was based on the law, not politics.
The unanimous decision was issued by two Democratic judges: Paul Ridgeway of Wake County and Alma Hinton of Halifax County ; and one Republican, Joseph Crosswhite of Iredell County.

“The conclusions of this Court today reflect the unanimous and best efforts of the undersigned trial judges — each hailing from different geographic regions and each with differing ideological and political outlooks — to apply core constitutional principles to this complex and divisive topic,” the judges wrote in their decision.

The judges’ ruling threw out State House and Senate maps that had been drawn in 2011 under the guidance of Republican political strategist, Thomas B. Hofeller, renowned for his skill in drafting partisan gerrymanders. Democrats in the Legislature were not allowed to meet Hofeller and had no role in the maps’ creation.

After the 2017 decision throwing out 28 districts as racially gerrymandered, legislative leaders told a federal court that racial statistics would not be used in drafting the new districts.

The resulting maps were summarized using results from 10 previous statewide elections. By that yardstick, the judges said, Republicans would have won a House and Senate supermajority in each of those 10 elections had the new districts been in effect.

Afterlast November’s midterm elections reduced Republicans to a minority of the vote statewide, the party still held on to 54 percent of State House seats and 58 percent of State Senate seats.

During the trial, the plaintiffs also claimed that Republican leaders misled the federal court when they claimed that race played no role in drawing the new districts. Data found on Hofeller’s computer after his death in August of last year showed that he had calculated the racial balance of every new district.

Candidate filing for the March 3rd primary begins Dec. 2nd — but the judges said they are serious about those elections being held using new maps. The judges gave the legislature just two weeks, until September 18th, to draw new maps. They ruled the new lines can be drawn to protect incumbents from being pitted against one another but can’t use any other political data.

Judges also told lawmakers they might reschedule the March 3rd Primary Election if the legislature can’t come up with new maps in time. “The Court retains jurisdiction to move the primary date for the General Assembly elections, or all of the State’s 2020 primaries, including for offices other than the General Assembly, should doing so become necessary."

Most of the affected NC House & Senate districts that will have to be redrawn are in the eastern part of the state.  In our area, the NC House districts in Gaston County (and one including part of Cleveland) will have to be redrawn.

to have us email you 
the latest news every day--

1 - Court Street Grill 300

Sign up for our FREE email service and we'll send you an email every day with links to our articles posted since the previous day's email.  That way, you won't miss the latest news, obituaries, sports and other items of interest for Lincoln, Gaston, Catawba & Cleveland counties.   

To make sure you get the latest updates, also like our Facebook page at and follow us on Twitter @LincolnHerald20.

1 - Lincolnton Animal Hospital - Sept

Article Comment Submission Form
Please feel free to submit your comments.

Article comments are not posted immediately to the Web site. Each submission must be approved by the Web site editor, who may edit content for appropriateness. There may be a delay of 24-48 hours for any submission while the web site editor reviews and approves it.

Note: All information on this form is required. Your telephone number is for our use only, and will not be attached to your comment.
Submit an Article Comment
First Name:
Last Name:
Anti-SPAM Passcode Click here to see a new mix of characters.
This is an anti-SPAM device. It is not case sensitive.

North Carolina News


HomeNewsState NewsReligionOpinionSportsObituariesExtrasCommunityClassifiedsSubmitLife
GastonCollege729x90 Sept-Oct

Terms and Use | Merchant Directory | Dining Guide
Site Design and Content
Copyright Lincoln Herald, LLC 2011-2019


Software © 1998-2019 1up! Software, All Rights Reserved